Campus Ledger
← UW–Whitewater review

Accounting instruction and placement

Read student excerpts, check who is counted in the placement headline, and see what the department told reviewers about staffing.

Accounting / Student reviews

What students say about Abbie Daly

Across multiple courses and years, students reviewing Abbie Daly’s accounting classes repeatedly describe fast-paced explanations, difficult exams, and having to learn material on their own. These excerpts come from anonymous Rate My Professors posts that rated the classes 1.0 or 2.0 out of 5 for quality. Two April 30 posts describe the class in nearly identical terms, so only one is quoted here. Read Daly’s Rate My Professors profile.

Why some students would avoid Daly’s classes

The November 19, 2026 Rate My Professors snapshot supplied to Campus Ledger lists Abbie Daly at 2.1 out of 5 for overall quality across 56 ratings and 4.1 out of 5 for difficulty. It displays 25% would take again. The snapshot does not give the number of people who answered that question.

Some reviewers describe unclear lectures, exams that carry much of the grade, and homework that felt disconnected from online lessons. Those comments explain why some students recommend choosing a different section. Experiences varied: an earlier snapshot listed 10 five-star ratings. These voluntary reviews offer a view into individual experiences. See Daly’s rating distribution and reviews.

Recent student comments

Two anonymous posts dated November 17, 2026 describe difficulty following the instruction in online ACCOUNT 343. The posts give different attendance requirements. The excerpts do not identify whether the reviewers took the same section.

ACCOUNT 343 · Online ·

Online instruction felt discouraging

Quality 1.0/5 · Difficulty 3.0/5

“Her teaching style makes already difficult accounting concepts harder to understand, and the course feels unnecessarily stressful.”

This post lists a C− and says attendance was optional. It describes the course as test-heavy, with few graded items.

ACCOUNT 343 · Online ·

Unclear explanations and little support

Quality 1.0/5 · Difficulty 3.0/5

“Her teaching methods lack clarity, and difficult accounting concepts are not explained effectively.”

This post lists a C+ and says attendance was mandatory. It describes the course as lecture-heavy and test-heavy.

ACCOUNT 244 ·

Flipped instruction

Quality 1.0/5 Difficulty 5.0/5

“Class was flipped, homework was done in class, and lectures were delivered by a different professor online.”

The reviewer described a fast lecture pace and a format that put lecture viewing outside class and homework inside class.

ACCOUNT 244 ·

Exams carry most of the grade

Quality 2.0/5 Difficulty 5.0/5

“Her tests are VERY HARD, and the majority of your grade is based on them.”

The reviewer said quizzes were frequent and open-note and open-book, and that the class project counted for little.

ACCOUNT 343 ·

Online lessons and homework felt disconnected

Quality 1.0/5 Difficulty 5.0/5

“Homework is almost never a representation of the lessons. Be ready to learn everything from the book.”

The reviewer described presentations as hard to follow and said they relied heavily on the textbook.

Earlier student comments

ACCT 341 ·

Quality 1.0/5 Difficulty 5.0/5

“Rather drop out then take again.”
ACCT 783 ·

Quality 1.0/5 Difficulty 5.0/5

“She does not give enough lecture to cover the material in exams.”
ACCT 341 ·

Quality 2.0/5 Difficulty 5.0/5

“Abbie is a nice woman, although she makes her exams extremely difficult without giving a study guide or anything else.”

A recurring complaint is the gap reviewers describe between what they practiced and what they faced on exams. If accounting is your intended major, look up who teaches your required sections and ask for a recent syllabus. Compare how much each exam counts, what practice materials students get, and how class time is used.

Abbie Daly’s teaching and leadership record

UW–Whitewater lists Daly as Accounting Department Chairperson. The college awarded her the Robert Gruber Accounting Professorship in 2021. In the announcement, Daly described her teaching as practical and emphasized data analysis and professional judgment. The award announcement describes her approach in her own words. Academic Affairs directory · College announcement.

The student excerpts raise a specific teaching question: how closely do the practice assignments prepare students for the exams that determine their grades? A 2025 reviewer of ACCOUNT 343 described a disconnect between homework and lessons, while a 2018 ACCT 341 reviewer described difficult exams without a study guide. The selected anonymous reviews provide individual accounts. A recent syllabus, representative practice materials, and anonymized section-level grade distributions would help assess how widespread or current the concerns are. Student review profile.

The 2024 accounting program review identifies Daly as department chair and records her suggestion to share the chair’s administrative workload. College leaders asked the program to specify whether it needed support for teaching, chair duties, or accreditation years. The review recommended continuing the program without qualification. The public summary leaves a concrete question for the department: what did it change after the review, and how did it measure whether students benefited? Program review, page 2.

The accounting department owes students better answers

Put the missing graduates next to the placement headline. In 2022–23, Whitewater knew the outcomes of 59 of 80 accounting graduates. A year later, it knew the outcomes of 46 of 71. Coverage fell from 73.8% to 64.8% while the headline stayed at 100%. Applicants should be able to see the full cohort, unknown outcomes, and how many graduates found full-time accounting work without having to reconstruct the numbers from a PDF. Compare the Career Services reports.

Show what changed after the staffing review. The department raised concerns about workload and resources in 2024. The dean and provost asked the department to identify whether it needed support for teaching, chair duties, or accreditation. Reviewers recommended continuing the program without qualification and asked it to improve online engagement. The public meeting summary does not show which steps were taken or whether they improved students’ experience. The department should publish an update naming the changes, who was responsible, and how it measured the results. Read the review recommendations.

Tell online students exactly what support they can get. The college publishes tutoring support for ACCOUNT 244 and 249. ACCOUNT 343 is absent from that list, and students reviewing its online instruction described difficulty following explanations. The department should publish support options by course, including hours, format, and who can help if no tutor is listed. A review of teaching should also check how well the assignments and practice materials prepare students for the assessments that carry the grade. Read the online support and tuition analysis · Read the student accounts.

UW–Whitewater should formally review accounting instruction

Several sources give UW–Whitewater specific problems to answer for. In the 2024 accounting program review, the department raised concerns about staffing and workload, and reviewers called for stronger engagement for online students. The public summary recommended continuing the program without qualification. It leaves open what the university changed in response to the concerns. 2024 accounting program review.

Career Services documented outcomes for 46 of 71 accounting graduates in 2023–24. The other 25 outcomes were unknown. Students reviewing Daly’s classes separately reported unclear explanations and trouble connecting lectures and assignments to exam preparation. The university should answer both concerns directly by publishing the counts behind its placement headline and examining how students are taught and assessed. Placement report and fact-check · Student accounts.

Campus Ledger calls for a formal review of Abbie Daly’s teaching and her work as accounting department chair. The university should appoint reviewers outside the department to examine recent syllabi, exam preparation materials, anonymized course evaluations and grade distributions, and actions taken since the 2024 review. Reviewers should invite Daly to respond and give students a confidential way to provide feedback. If the findings establish persistent shortcomings that corrective steps cannot address, the university should consider reassigning teaching duties or appointing a new chair.

Why we’d compare other business schools first

Whitewater’s accounting reviews give applicants a reason to check who teaches the required courses before committing. Several public profiles have low overall scores, while another has a substantially higher score. The experience students describe can vary widely by instructor and section.

Swipe or scroll to see all columns.

Selected Rate My Professors profile summaries
InstructorQuality / 5Rating countWould take again
Victoria Torino1.72118%
Robert Yu2.95156%
Abbie Daly2.15625%
Brian Huels4.83995%

A September 2026 reviewer of Yu’s online ACCOUNT 244 gave the class 5/5 for quality and said assignments, discussions, and exams carried a balanced share of the grade. A June 2026 reviewer of Huels’s online ACCOUNT 244 praised his availability and said the lectures were easy to follow. These details give applicants concrete things to compare with the complaints elsewhere on this page. The ratings are voluntary, span different courses and terms, and can change. Daly’s figures come from the supplied snapshot. The “would take again” percentages may use fewer responses than the overall rating counts.

Our recommendation for prospective business students: compare other schools before choosing Whitewater, especially for accounting. Its business and accounting accreditation is a strength, while the placement headline leaves 25 of 71 graduate outcomes unknown and the 2024 program review raised workload and resource concerns. Ask each school for current syllabi, section availability, and placement figures broken down by major and cohort size. These accounting records provide the strongest evidence for this recommendation. Whitewater’s placement records · Compare UW–Madison’s business and accounting outcomes.

Where students say accounting instruction falls short

A demanding course can still give students clear explanations, useful feedback, and a respectful response when they ask for help. The reviews below describe where those expectations were met or missed. Each score is the reviewer’s rating on a five-point scale.

Victoria Torino

ACC 249 · April 23, 2026 · 1/5 quality. A reviewer said the explanations were hard to follow and that they ended up teaching themselves the material. That raises a course-design question: can students see a worked example, practice the same skill, and get feedback before they are graded on it? Torino’s student reviews.

Robert Yu

ACCOUNT 244 · May 11, 2026 · 1/5 quality. A reviewer said they felt brushed off when they asked for help, waited for email responses and grades, and turned to tutoring. An April 29 reviewer gave the same course 1/5 and said they used outside videos to learn basic journal entries. A September reviewer of online ACCOUNT 244 gave 5/5 and found the problem walkthroughs helpful. Yu’s student reviews.

A student who asks for help deserves a clear and respectful response. The report of feeling dismissed deserves follow-up alongside the positive experience another reviewer described. The department should check whether each section sets clear expectations for response times and feedback, offers worked examples, and gives students a dependable way to get help. These anonymous ratings describe individual experiences across different sections and terms. Read the department accountability analysis.

University records

What the accounting records show

Two independent publications examine how UW–Whitewater presents its accounting program to applicants. Their coverage points to two university records worth reading before choosing the major. The Whitewater Record · True College Verdict’s “Behind The Warhawk Brand”

Fact check / Accounting placement

What happened to the 25 graduates outside the “100%”?

UW–Whitewater’s accounting degree page advertises “100% career and graduate school placement.” The text beneath the headline specifies “2023-24 research survey respondents.” The department page makes a broader “100 percent placement rate for accounting majors within six months of graduation” claim without that qualification in the sentence. Accounting degree page · Accounting department page

Career Services reported outcomes for 46 of 71 graduates (64.8%) in 2023–24. Of those 46, 44 were employed and two were continuing their education. The other 25 outcomes were unknown. In 2022–23, the same 100% figure covered 59 of 80 graduates (73.8%) whose outcomes were known. The headline gives readers no way to tell how much of the graduating class was counted. UW–Whitewater should put those counts next to the percentage. 2023–24 Career Services report · 2022–23 Career Services report

2024 / Program review

Accounting flagged staffing pressure

In February 2024, the accounting program told reviewers it was concerned about how much work it had to complete with its existing staffing and resources. College leadership said it was helping streamline the work to avoid burnout. Reviewers recommended continuing the program without qualification and asked the department to keep improving engagement for online students. The meeting summary gives applicants a concrete question to ask today: what staffing or online support changed after the review? Read the university’s meeting summary.

Program status

Staffing concerns at an active program

The university currently lists its accounting bachelor’s degree, and AACSB lists accreditation in both business and accounting. The 2024 review documents workload concerns and recommends improving online engagement. Applicants should ask what staffing and online support have changed since that review. Current degree listing · AACSB directory

What accounting applicants should ask for

Ask the department to publish the total cohort, the number with known outcomes, and the number employed in accounting or related work next to each placement rate. The destination tables count employment and continuing education together, so a placement percentage cannot tell you how many graduates entered accounting jobs.

For a required class, ask for the current syllabus, exam weights, worked practice problems, and tutoring coverage. The anonymous excerpts above span multiple courses and years. They document reported experiences and give applicants concrete questions to raise with the department.

Compare two graduating classes

Swipe or scroll to see all columns.

Accounting first-destination results
Graduating classAll graduatesKnown outcomesEmployedContinuing educationUnknown
2022–23805956321
2023–24714644225

Coverage fell from 73.8% to 64.8% while placement among graduates with known outcomes stayed at 100%. That is a nine-percentage-point drop in coverage. The public figures do not resolve whether the change reflects differences in tracking, response, or the graduates whose outcomes could be found.

2022–23 Career Services table · 2023–24 Career Services table.

What the next accounting review should document

The February 2024 meeting summary identifies administrative work tied to accreditation, online programming, and outreach. The department chair suggested a co-chair model. The provost and dean asked the program to clarify whether its resource need was for chair duties, teaching, or accreditation years. The report calls for the next short self-study in 2030.

That leaves a specific accountability question today. Ask which responsibilities were reassigned, what academic support online students actually used, and whether the school measured participation and results. Accounting review recommendations and timeline.

The online course format changes cost and support

Whitewater’s College of Business and Economics says traditional tuition rates and the 12-credit tuition plateau do not apply to its online courses. A student mixing online and in-person classes should request a written estimate for the exact schedule. Compare charges again if an online section is the only one that fits around work or a prerequisite.

The college lists online tutoring for ACCOUNT 244 and 249, among several other courses. ACCOUNT 343 is absent from that published list. Ask whether support for 343 or other upper-level accounting courses is available separately and whether hours work for students who cannot come to campus. This matters for applicants reading student reports about unclear online instruction. College online-learning policies · Current subject tutoring directory.

How to turn a grading concern into a specific question

If a student wants a review of a grade, the university publishes a grade-appeal route. Its Dean of Students page also describes a general grievance process. Start by identifying the issue and the deadline. Keep the syllabus, assignment instructions, grading rubric, and feedback, then identify what decision you are asking the school to examine.

A section-level review could look at whether quizzes, homework, and exams test the same learning objectives and whether students had representative practice. Published student reviews can identify questions like those. A fair assessment requires the materials used in the course and a response from the instructor or department. Whitewater grievance and appeal procedures.

More on UW–Whitewater

How consistent is the placement headline?

In 2022–23, the university documented employment or continued education for 59 of 80 accounting graduates. In 2023–24, it documented those outcomes for 46 of 71. The number with known positive outcomes fell by 13, while the graduating class shrank by nine. Twenty-one outcomes were unknown in the earlier class and 25 in the later class.

The reports count employment and continuing education together. In the later class, 44 graduates were recorded as employed and two were recorded as continuing their education. The table has no field for whether graduates were employed in accounting. If the program uses this figure to promote career preparation, it should publish occupation, reporting coverage, and program cohort size alongside the percentage.

2022–23 destination report · 2023–24 destination report.